7 Best Shoes for Broken Toe 2023 – Review and Buying Guide

A broken toe brings incomparable discomfort and pain. The situation gets worse when doctors suggest the rest for a long healing period. Of course, you cannot stick yourself to bed for such a long time. The good news is that you can walk even with a broken toe. You can get many shoes specially designed to help you deal with broken toes.

These shoes have delicate features like a semi-rigid sole, support for the broken toes, adjustable sizes, and wide and open fronts. These shoes help you walk with broken toes without getting a further injury. We tried out the seven best shoes for broken toes that you can buy in 2023. Here is a detailed review that will let you know what each shoe offers to an individual with a broken toe.

Top Shoes For Broken Toes

1. BraceAbility Short Broken Toe Boot

 

BraceAbility Short broken-toe shoes are clinically proven to provide protection and relief while healing and walking with a broken toe. The shoe has an open front with a wide toe area, offering enough room for the broken toe to relax. Moreover, it has a deluxe foam liner that provides additional comfort and cushion to the injured or broken toes or any other foot part.

We loved the adjustable straps that let you customize the size and make the shoe comfortable for swollen and bandaged feet. The feature that sets this shoe apart from its counterparts is its versatility. The shoe doesn’t only help you deal with toes but is also useful for ankle injury, fracture, tendon injury, and foot surgeries.

Also, the shoe is covered in a polymer plastic shell, which provides the cushion and restricts the movement of the broken or injured ankle and toe. This feature helps you heal the injury quickly and facilities walking.

Additionally, it keeps the foot from bending and turning while walking, making it extremely useful for people with broken toes. The shoes are available in standard sizes of men 6-8 and women 6.5-9. To get the best out of this shoe, it is important to select the right size of the shoe. Finally, we were obsessed with the rocker sole of the shoe. The sole is flexible yet rigid, offering maximum support and cushion to the foot.

 

If you are looking for a multi-purpose shoe to get support for your ankle, fractured metatarsal, and a broken ankle, this Braceability short shoe is highly recommended. It features a customizable design coupled with foam lining and a rocker sole, making it the best shoe for a broken toe in 2023.

2. United Ortho Short Air Cam Walker Fracture Boot

 

United ortho Short Air cam is the best shoe for natural walking experience for individuals with broken toes or serious foot injuries. The shoe doesn’t come cheap, but it offers unmatched ergonomics and quality, offering the best value for money. The most standout feature of the shoe is the semi-rigid rocker sole. This rocker sole provides the arch-support while keeping your toes straight and intact while walking.

Also, it is flexible enough and ensures a natural and comfortable walking experience. We loved the hard-shell design of the shoe. This construction is beneficial for healing from a foot injury, especially broken toes. It keeps the broken bones straight and aligned and keeps them from bending and turning. The softly padded removable lining further enhances the comfort of the shoe.

The lining provides a cushion and acts as a shock-absorbent, and prevents the broken toes from further damage. We also loved the air-bladders on the upper part of the shoe. Air-bladders facilitate the airflow, reducing the heat-build-up and making the shoe breathable.

The shoe has ankle support that keeps the foot in the right posture. Plus, a velcro-opening design makes it easier to take your foot in and out of the shoe. The only disappointing thing is that the shoe offers a limited size adjustment. The shoe is available in US standard size for men from 7-9 and women 8.5-10.5. If you want to get the best out of this shoe, it is important to make a wise size choice.

 

United Ortho-Air Cam is the best choice for people who want a natural walking experience with broken toes.  The shoe features a premium construction quality and incredible ergonomics, making it one of the best shoes for a broken toe in 2023.

3. FitPro Adjustable Post-Op Open Square Toe Shoe

 

FitPro Open Square toe shoe is our next pick for the best shoes for broken toes. It’s an affordable shoe that is designed to provide Post-Op comfort to injured feet. The feature we found promising is its square toe design. The square toe design promises comfort when you have more than one broken toe.

You can use this shoe for either left or right shoes-thanks to its square toe design. Additionally, it is available in large sizes, and you can choose between 8.5-10 standard women’s sizes.  Plus, the shoe offers adjustability, making the shoe perfect for swollen feet. This feature also lets us use this shoe even with the thick and heavy dressings.

Additionally, it uses a blend of rocker soles that pride unmatched flexibility and require support for injured feet while walking. The flexibility aids in pain release while the support and rigidity keep your toe from bending.

Finally, we loved the wide and velcro opening of the shoes. It was effortless to apply and remove the shoes without getting the injured toe hurt. Remember that shoes don’t offer ankle support and are not suitable if you have an ankle bone injury or related pain issues.

 

FitPro adjustable square toe shoe offers the maximum comfort and support for your one or more injured toes while walking. Additionally, it comes with wide velcro openings that let you easily apply and remove the shoes safely without getting in contact with the broken toe.

4. BraceAbility Post-op Shoe for Broken Foot or Toe

 

Our shoe is best for both men and women who have broken toes or foot operations-says the manufacturer. Braceability Post-OP shoes are available in US standard shoe sizes for men and women and fit some oversized teens. The feature that we find most stands out is the rigid and supportive sole of the shoe.

It provides you the required arch support, keeps your toe straight, and prevents the turning and bending of the toe while walking.  Plus, it has an anti-skid sole that provides you the traction making the shoe non-slippery on wet surfaces. Furthermore, we were impressed by the open square front of the shoe.

The front is spacious that accommodates the swollen and broken toes and prevents further damage. The shoe also features two-velcro straps. These straps make it easier to apply and remove the shoe.  Also, straps let you customize the size of the shoe for swelling and bandages.

Finally, we found this shoe very safe and comfortable while walking with a broken toe. It has an orthopedic foam lining inside that feels soft on the foot, absorbs the shock, and provides the required flexibility while walking.

 

If you are looking for a shoe with a soft inner lining and rigid sole, consider this Post-op shoe by Braceabilty. This shoe provides the required cushion and arch support to the broken toe and aids in speedy recovery.

5. Orthowedge Forefoot Off-Loading Healing Shoe

 

Orthowedge Forefoot is another square front shoe that is ideal for both left and right foot. The shoes feature a 15% dorsi-bottom that is specially designed for people with broken toes, diabetic ulcers, or a forefoot fracture. The 15-degree lifted soul leaves the front part lifted and puts all the pressure on heels as you walk. Therefore it is ideal for individuals with broken toes or metatarsal fractures.

It releases all the pressure and weight from toes and broken toes and keeps them from bending and turning. We found this shoe very promising in healing the broken toes. Plus, the shoe has a wide square opening, which means it has enough room to accommodate the broken toes and prevents further injury and damage.

The feature we loved the most is the soft inner side of the shoe. It has a soft yet breathable inner side with a removable orthopedic insole. The removable insole is lightweight and provides the added cushion and support for the injured foot while walking. The shoe comes with adjustable straps that let you customize the size, making the shoe perfect for bandages.

Finally, I loved the padded and hard sole of the shoes. It is rigid enough to prevent feet from bending during walking and also prevents slipping in all weathers. This shoe is specially designed to deal with broken toes and forefront issues and is not ideal for people having ankle or heel issues.

 

If you have one or more broken toes and you want to get them to heal quickly, Orthowedge Forefoot Off-load shoes are the best option you can have. With a 15-degree angle sole, it releases all the pressure from the forefoot and aids in the speedy recovery of broken toes.

6. Complete Medical Darco Med-Surg Shoe

 

Complete medical Draco is an affordable orthopedic shoe that is ideal for people having one or more broken toes. The shoe comes with features of durable and lightweight construction, making it ideal for post-operation foot recovery. Despite its competitive price, the shoe doesn’t compromise on quality and features. We were impressed by the shoe’s design as it provides unmatched comfort and relaxation while walking with a broken toe.

The shoe has a square open-front that is spacious enough to accommodate broken and swollen toes. It also prevents further damage of toes while walking. Also, the bottom is rigid enough to provide arch-support to the broken toe and prevents bending. The only thing we found a bit annoying is its rigid sole. The sole of the shoe is comparatively harder than other shoes on the list. It lacks flexibility and therefore may cause discomfort in heels.

The shoe has a wide and easy opening of velcro straps. Velcro straps make it easier to apply and remove the shoe without hurting the broken toes. Also, velcro straps allow size customization to accommodate the swollen parts and dressings.

We loved the ankle support provided by the toe. A strap near the ankle helps you keep your injured foot in the right posture for a safe and comfortable walking experience. Finally, the shoe is hand washable and easy to clean, which is a real plus.

 

This is one of the most competitively priced orthopedic shoes that aids in speedy recovery and healing of broken toes. It has a wide opening, adjustable design, unmatched arch-support, and ankle support, making it one of the best shoes for a broken toe you can buy in 2023.

7. DMI Cast Shoe, Cast Boot

 

Finally, we have an affordable yet beneficial shoe that can help women in natural walking with one or more broken toes. The shoe is available for US standard size for women between 6-8 and offers size adjustability and customization to accommodate the bandage as well.

The feature that impressed us most is impressive construction quality coupled with an ergonomic design.  It features an open-front design coupled with a nylon construction. The nylon mesh feels soft on feet, facilitates air circulation, and prevents heat buildup, making the shoe comfortable for injured feet.

Moreover, it has non-kid semi-rigid soles that provide you traction over slippery surfaces.  The softly padded inner sole absorbs the shocks and provides the cushion giving you a natural and safe walking experience. The only thing it lacks is a square front opening.

It has a round opening that doesn’t provide enough room for the swollen and banged broken toes. Finally, it has a hook and loop velcro opening that makes the shoe removal and application a breeze. Also, it lets you customize the size of the shoe to accommodate the dressings.

 

DMI cast shoe is an affordable shoe for women with broken toes or foot injuries. The hoe has a breathable construction and an ergonomic design that aids in natural waking and helps in speedy recovery.

Buyer’s Guide

The shoe choice is of critical importance when you have one or more broken toes. You cannot just randomly pick any pair of shoes that looks comfortable. Buying the right shoe for a broken toe will aid in the toe’s speedy recovery and prevent further damage. Shoes designed for broken toes have some dedicated features that make them ideal for individuals with broken toes. Here are the features you must look for in a shoe for a broken toe in 2023.

Rigid Or Soft

In general, we can say that soft shoes are more comfortable than rigid ones. Therefore, we should go with a soft pair of shoes if we have a broken toe. However, the truth is the opposite. If we have a broken toe, we need to keep it straight and aligned while walking, and therefore we need a rigid and supportive shoe. Also, keep in mind that shoes should not be too rigid. Hard and rigid shoes lack flexibility and may feel uncomfortable while walking.

Construction Quality

As we are convinced that we need semi-rigid shoes, it is important to look for the quality of the shoe. Poor quality material does not provide the required cushion and support for broken toes. Therefore we should go with shoes made with high-quality materials that provide support and flexibility to the broken part of the foot while walking.

Open Front

The open front is a must-have if you are looking for a shoe for a broken toe. The broken toes require enough room and space to rest safely, and a shoe with a closed front cannot provide that. Plus, there is a chance of heat build-up, which can cause restlessness, discomfort, and even pain in the broken part.

An open forefront shoe also provides aeration to keep your toe relaxed. Also, there are chances of swelling in the broken toes, and a closed forefront shoe cannot accommodate the swollen toes.

Closure

The closure system is another critical part of the shoe designed for broken toes. The shoe should offer a facilitated and easy removal and application of the shoe. A strap enclosure is the best choice for people having broken toes or feet injury.

Straps allow you to easily get your foot in and out from the shoe without hurting the broken toe. Additionally, straps offer adjustability and help you customize the shoe for swelling and bandage.

Sole

Good sole helps you get the ease of walking with broken toes. It is recommended to buy a flexible yet semi-rigid sole. The rigidity of the sole provides support and also keeps the toe from bending while walking. Also, it should be flexible enough for a comfortable walking experience. Plus, the bottom should have an anti-skid feature. It will provide traction and let you walk safely in all weather conditions.

Size

Right fit is the most critical factor for any shoe. Shoes for broken or injured feet are available in different standard sizes. Keep in mind that the size you should buy for these shoes could be different from your regular size. You should go for the shoe size that can accommodate the dressing and swollen parts of your feet.

Other things to Consider

Ankle support is another important feature to look for in shoes for broken toes. Ankle support provides additional support to the feet and aids in walking around with broken toes. Also, you can buy shoes with an angled heel that keeps your forefoot lifted and puts all the pressure on the heels. It helps you in fast recovery. Finally, you should seek a doctor’s advice before buying a shoe for the broken toe.

FAQs

What shoes should I wear with a broken toe?

Wearing a regular shoe with a broken toe is not recommended. Instead, you should get a shoe with a relatively stiff sole, breathable construction, customizable size, and a wide front opening. These shoes will provide the required support and cushion to the broken toes and facilitate the healing process.

How long do I have to wear a boot for a broken toe?

Depending upon the severity of the fracture, the doctor will suggest you a boot for 1-6 weeks. It also depends upon physical activities. If you want a natural walking experience and continue your regular physical activities, this period could be as long as up to 7 weeks.

Can you take a walking boot off to sleep?

Yes, you can take off the walking boot to sleep. However, it is recommended to consult your doctor for the bandage and dressing you should use at night to keep your toe straight, aligned, and intact.

Wrapping Up

We can safely conclude that having the right shoe for a broken toe is critical for a speedy recovery and natural walking. All the shoes reviewed above are medically proven and offer the best value for money. With our personal analysis, we have picked up our top three favorites.

FitPro Adjustable Post-Op Open Square Toe Shoe for its square toe design, semi-rigid rocker sole, affordable price, and customizable size.

Orthowedge Forefoot Off-Loading Healing Shoe for its customizable design, removable orthopedic in-sole, 1-degree angled sole and non-slip bottom.

DMI Cast Shoe, Cast Boot for its softly padded inner-sole, affordable price, breathable nylon construction, and hook-loop velcro opening.

Finally, It is recommended to consult your doctor before buying a shoe for a broken toe.

 

Take a look at these shoes for broken toes also: